Am Politician
BackAm Politician stands as one of the most distinctive restaurants in the Outer Hebrides, offering visitors an experience that seamlessly blends excellent pub fare, fascinating local history, and breathtaking coastal scenery. Located in the small settlement of Balla on Eriskay, this establishment has earned its reputation as an essential stop for anyone exploring the Scottish islands, particularly those travelling the Hebridean Way.
The pub takes its name from the ill-fated SS Politician, which ran aground off the coast of Eriskay in 1941. The vessel was carrying an extraordinary cargo of approximately 22,000 cases of whisky alongside £3 million in Jamaican bank notes. This incident inspired Sir Compton Mackenzie’s famous novel Whisky Galore!, which was later adapted into a beloved British comedy film. The pub proudly displays memorabilia from this historic shipwreck, including original whisky bottles recovered from the wreckage and various artefacts from that era. Staff members are known for sharing the fascinating story with interested visitors, making a visit here feel like stepping into a living piece of Scottish cultural history.
When it comes to food and dining, Am Politician has earned widespread praise for its commitment to quality and value. The menu showcases local seafood prominently, with hand-dived scallops receiving particular acclaim from diners. Visitors consistently describe them as the freshest and most perfectly cooked they’ve experienced. The monkfish scampi has become something of a signature dish, with multiple reviewers declaring it the best they’ve ever tasted. Traditional fish and chips also receive high marks, with the fish described as exceptionally fresh and the portions generous.
The steak pie emerges as another standout option in numerous reviews, with visitors travelling specifically to sample this dish and declaring it the best they’ve encountered in the UK. Hearty options like lamb shanks, lasagne, and chicken schnitzel round out the menu, ensuring there’s something for every palate. The establishment maintains reasonable prices for its quality, with many diners expressing pleasant surprise at the value for money offered. Those seeking lighter options will find soup and sandwich meal deals available, while a dedicated gluten-free menu with impressive variety demonstrates the kitchen’s attention to diverse dietary requirements.
The conservatory dining area at the rear of the establishment deserves special mention. Overlooking the coastline, it provides panoramic views that guests describe as spectacular, particularly during sunset. Several reviewers specifically recommend requesting a table in the conservatory to make the most of this feature. The beer garden offers additional outdoor seating with direct access to a pristine sandy beach, making it perfect for warm weather dining or a refreshing drink after exploring the coast. Families appreciate this setup, as children can play on the sand while parents relax with refreshments.
Service at Am Politician consistently receives positive feedback. Staff members are characterised as friendly, welcoming, and attentive across the vast majority of reviews. Multiple visitors note the genuine warmth of the welcome, with particular praise for proprietors Julia and Stephen. The team accommodates various needs, including dog-friendly policies in the bar area, making it a popular choice for those walking the coastal paths of South Uist with furry companions. Evening entertainment occasionally features live music and traditional Scottish dancing, adding to the authentic island pub atmosphere.
Accessibility and practical considerations are well addressed. The establishment is wheelchair accessible, and the car park provides ample space for those arriving by vehicle. Reservations are strongly recommended, particularly for evening meals, as the venue proves extremely popular with both locals and visitors. Several reviewers experienced disappointment when arriving without booking during busy periods. The pub opens daily from noon, with slightly later Sunday opening at 12:30 PM, closing at 10 PM each evening.
While the overwhelming majority of experiences are positive, a small number of visitors have reported issues worth noting. A few diners found certain dishes occasionally dry, with the lasagne and burger mentioned in isolated reviews. One particularly negative experience involved rudeness from kitchen staff, though this appears to be an exception rather than the norm. Some visitors felt the exterior building appeared somewhat dated, though the interior and views more than compensate for this first impression.
For those planning a visit to Eriskay or South Uist, Am Politician represents an unmissable destination. The combination of excellent locally-sourced food, rich historical connections, stunning natural surroundings, and genuine island hospitality creates an experience that resonates with all who visit. Whether stopping for a pint, enjoying a full restaurant meal, or simply absorbing the atmosphere and history, this establishment embodies the best of what Hebridean hospitality has to offer.